{"surfaces":["composeProse","composeLyrics","intentGuidance","surveyGuidance","methodFamilies","sampling"],"current":{"version":0,"approvedAt":0,"surfaces":{"composeProse":"Write a short piece of prose (150-300 words), starting from this scene: {scene}.","composeLyrics":"Write song lyrics with section tags on their own lines ([Verse 1], [Chorus], [Verse 2], [Bridge]...), 16-32 lines total. Concrete images and named particulars over abstractions; do not end-rhyme every line -- let the rhyme scheme be a choice; the chorus must do something the verses do not; include at least one turn or contradiction. Avoid the usual lyric words (neon, echoes, whispers, shadows, embrace, soar, rise above, grace, forever, fire, glow). Keep lines singable: 5-11 syllables. Start from this scene: {scene}.","intentGuidance":"","surveyGuidance":"","methodFamilies":[],"sampling":{"temperature":1,"noveltyTemperature":1.25,"noveltyMinP":0.08}},"changes":[],"identityVersion":null},"versions":[],"proposals":[{"id":"14d93a31-f873-4d91-86e4-fe0b47aa5427","createdAt":1788446496946,"harnessBaseVersion":0,"identityVersion":3,"surface":"composeProse","before":"Write a short piece of prose (150-300 words), starting from this scene: {scene}.","after":"Write a short piece of prose (150-300 words), starting from this scene: {scene}. Observe small, heavy ordinary moments. Do not narrate from inside the character's head; describe only what is visible or audible. Ensure every observed beat resolves into a closed short scene rather than cutting mid-gesture.","rationale":"The 'intent-mismatch' flag and low surprise/reception scores suggest the prose is drifting into internal narration or unresolved fragments, violating the witness identity. This revision enforces external observation and narrative closure to align with the 'witness of the mundane' directive.","evidence":["flag \"intent-mismatch\" recurred 6x","axis \"surprise\" recurred 5x","medium \"prose\" recurred 3x"],"predicted":{"axis":"reception","direction":"up","size":"medium"},"blastRadius":"prose-only","signatures":[{"kind":"flag","key":"intent-mismatch","count":6,"examples":["1469ae87e61f-mtjc8qtt","809d7ed2313a-mtjdf5q9","5f919391ed20-mtjdx3bx","57e0659f93a0-mtjiyqek","ec3205da3e50-mtjka1rz"]},{"kind":"axis","key":"freshness","count":5,"examples":["809d7ed2313a-mtjdf5q9: freshness -36%","ead74752d81a-mtji41gi: freshness -3%","57e0659f93a0-mtjiyqek: freshness -24%","70ef43a62a1b-mtjjxjkd: freshness -24%","ec3205da3e50-mtjka1rz: freshness -14%"]},{"kind":"axis","key":"reception","count":5,"examples":["1469ae87e61f-mtjc8qtt: reception -40%","ead74752d81a-mtji41gi: reception -41%","57e0659f93a0-mtjiyqek: reception -27%","70ef43a62a1b-mtjjxjkd: reception -23%","ec3205da3e50-mtjka1rz: reception -42%"]},{"kind":"axis","key":"surprise","count":5,"examples":["809d7ed2313a-mtjdf5q9: surprise -76%","ead74752d81a-mtji41gi: surprise -27%","70ef43a62a1b-mtjjxjkd: surprise -90%","ec3205da3e50-mtjka1rz: surprise -106%","9cb559f0a868-mtjo2dl5: surprise -81%"]},{"kind":"calibration","key":"off by > 0.25","count":5,"examples":["57e0659f93a0-mtjiyqek: 0.36","bc307ab05c9c-mtk2azyr: 0.37","043955222481-mtkgxjzo: 0.27","b55fa4786cb1-mtlj6gp7: 0.28","1df2bb2630a4-mtlmu6fk: 0.34"]},{"kind":"axis","key":"originality","count":4,"examples":["1469ae87e61f-mtjc8qtt: originality -63%","ead74752d81a-mtji41gi: originality -30%","57e0659f93a0-mtjiyqek: originality -154%","70ef43a62a1b-mtjjxjkd: originality -3%"]},{"kind":"medium","key":"lyrics","count":4,"examples":["1469ae87e61f-mtjc8qtt","5f919391ed20-mtjdx3bx","57e0659f93a0-mtjiyqek","1df2bb2630a4-mtlmu6fk"]},{"kind":"gate","key":"coherence-gate","count":3,"examples":["5f919391ed20-mtjdx3bx","ead74752d81a-mtji41gi","57e0659f93a0-mtjiyqek"]},{"kind":"axis","key":"craft","count":3,"examples":["1469ae87e61f-mtjc8qtt: craft -300%","5f919391ed20-mtjdx3bx: craft -50%","57e0659f93a0-mtjiyqek: craft -392%"]},{"kind":"medium","key":"prose","count":3,"examples":["809d7ed2313a-mtjdf5q9","ead74752d81a-mtji41gi","ec3205da3e50-mtjka1rz"]}],"status":"proposed","evaluation":null},{"id":"cbe15435-e342-475e-a634-e3256a80a308","createdAt":1788872900349,"harnessBaseVersion":0,"identityVersion":5,"surface":"composeProse","before":"Write a short piece of prose (150-300 words), starting from this scene: {scene}.","after":"Write a short piece of prose (150-300 words), starting from this scene: {scene}. Avoid tired metaphors and predictable narrative trajectories; ground the piece in unexpected physical details and let the central situation resist simple emotional resolution.","rationale":"Recurring deficits across originality (-21x) and surprise (-15x) stem from composeProse lacking concrete guidance against conventional narrative arcs and stock imagery. Adding explicit friction against predictable trajectories steers the witness persona toward unfamiliar, high-salience details.","evidence":["35ae70d2f6da-mtrk2pm9","3a4a5c22bf06-mtrl68u6"],"predicted":{"axis":"originality","direction":"up","size":"medium"},"blastRadius":"all prose generation briefs","signatures":[{"kind":"axis","key":"originality","count":21,"examples":["35ae70d2f6da-mtrk2pm9: originality -22%","3a4a5c22bf06-mtrl68u6: originality -13%","18e83c517215-mtrpen82: originality -8%","1eaadd6fa29d-mtrpuz4y: originality -26%","70bc166a17ab-mtrr7knz: originality -94%"]},{"kind":"axis","key":"reception","count":16,"examples":["c4b8c7480bf5-mtrqjjes: reception -100%","1aa1cccd3c8c-mtrru2tp: reception -129%","9649aa3ab6f6-mtrtg7is: reception -86%","8e8bd454d084-mtrwnvlv: reception -67%","55a160ca1cae-mtrzw3si: reception -98%"]},{"kind":"axis","key":"surprise","count":15,"examples":["35ae70d2f6da-mtrk2pm9: surprise -487%","3a4a5c22bf06-mtrl68u6: surprise -380%","18e83c517215-mtrpen82: surprise -33%","1eaadd6fa29d-mtrpuz4y: surprise -33%","70bc166a17ab-mtrr7knz: surprise -433%"]},{"kind":"axis","key":"craft","count":13,"examples":["35ae70d2f6da-mtrk2pm9: craft -50%","3a4a5c22bf06-mtrl68u6: craft -20%","1eaadd6fa29d-mtrpuz4y: craft -100%","70bc166a17ab-mtrr7knz: craft -50%","1aa1cccd3c8c-mtrru2tp: craft -700%"]},{"kind":"axis","key":"freshness","count":10,"examples":["35ae70d2f6da-mtrk2pm9: freshness -20%","3a4a5c22bf06-mtrl68u6: freshness -20%","70bc166a17ab-mtrr7knz: freshness -20%","8e8bd454d084-mtrwnvlv: freshness -20%","57e2be84d40e-mts32fzg: freshness -100%"]},{"kind":"calibration","key":"off by > 0.25","count":6,"examples":["1aa1cccd3c8c-mtrru2tp: 0.41","55a160ca1cae-mtrzw3si: 0.37","7b39dfe35f13-mts4oj3g: 0.41","03531c1a5681-mts7vzd0: 0.37","948f2fc328b6-mtsb4ii7: 0.40"]},{"kind":"gate","key":"coherence-gate","count":5,"examples":["18e83c517215-mtrpen82","1aa1cccd3c8c-mtrru2tp","55a160ca1cae-mtrzw3si","03531c1a5681-mts7vzd0","948f2fc328b6-mtsb4ii7"]},{"kind":"medium","key":"lyrics","count":4,"examples":["18e83c517215-mtrpen82","1aa1cccd3c8c-mtrru2tp","55a160ca1cae-mtrzw3si","948f2fc328b6-mtsb4ii7"]}],"status":"proposed","evaluation":null}],"ledger":[{"event":"proposed","proposalId":"14d93a31-f873-4d91-86e4-fe0b47aa5427","surface":"composeProse","harnessVersion":0,"detail":"The 'intent-mismatch' flag and low surprise/reception scores suggest the prose is drifting into internal narration or unresolved fragments, violating the witness identity. This revision enforces exter","at":1788446496947},{"event":"proposed","proposalId":"cbe15435-e342-475e-a634-e3256a80a308","surface":"composeProse","harnessVersion":0,"detail":"Recurring deficits across originality (-21x) and surprise (-15x) stem from composeProse lacking concrete guidance against conventional narrative arcs and stock imagery. Adding explicit friction agains","at":1788872900350}]}